“Too Clever by Half” is an expression that relates to someone being over confident in their cleverness and thus susceptible to overreach (wordreference.com). In other words, they overplay their hand in a cutsie way. I think in the ministry it is tempting to try to be needlessly provocative. Sometimes pastors can try to push the envelope in ways that are not good. I can’t help but to think of the recent controvery involving Andy Stanley and Northpoint Church
Personally, I have always enjoyed listening to Andy preach. He is a very gifted communicator and up to this point he has been extremely solid in his theology. He has been cutting edge in some of his methodology and that is perfectly fine with me. However, his message that he preached on April 15, needs some biblical clarification. I am sure that his motivation was noble, but the message he delivered was well below the standard that people have come to expect from him.
I follow Andy on twitter and I was curious when I read his tweet on April 14. The tweet said, “Our Atl area churches will for sure be a No-Sleep zone tomorrow. Something to offend everyone!” I remember thinking he must be going to make a pretty big announcement or something. Now, in retrospect it seems that he knew his statements would stir the pot among Christians and in particular pastors. So, the controversial nature of his message was no accident. It was anticipated and that is what I find most troubling. No doubt, Andy has a huge desire to reach people with the gospel of Jesus Christ. However, it seems that he catered his April 15 message more around a personal relationship than around Scripture. This is just my opinion as I try to make sense of why he would deliver a message that seems to be incongruent with his previous biblical convictions.
Andy Stanley has done great things for the Kingdom of God. However, he is not bigger than Scripture. The believers at Barea in the book of Acts were commended for examining Scripture to make sure that what the Apostle Paul told them was accurate. So, if the Bareans held Paul to the standard of Scripture then we should do no less in the twenty-first century. My hope is that Andy Stanley will clarify his statements as soon as possible. His track record has earned him the right to do so.

